Programmatic Advertising: Is AI Coming for Media Traders?
AI is moving into programmatic advertising, from media planning to campaign optimisation. So here is the uncomfortable question: what happens to Media Traders when an AI supervisor can do the operational work of an entire team? And could programmatic curation give agencies a way to reinvent themselves?
My prediction: AI will reduce the amount of manual media trading required, while shifting human expertise towards supervision, strategy and the creation of new advertising products. One opportunity for agencies in France and beyond is to help advertisers build their own curated ad networks.
AI-powered programmatic buying is already taking shape
The signs are everywhere. The Ad Context Protocol (AdCP) is emerging as a protocol for AI-assisted advertising workflows. Demand-side platforms (DSPs) such as Google Display & Video 360, The Trade Desk and Amazon DSP are developing AI features for media planning, campaign setup, reporting and creative optimisation. On the supply side, platforms such as Equativ, with Maestro, are also pushing automation. Start-ups including Concord.ad and Supply Finder are exploring ways to simplify buying with another layer of AI (the exact features and availability vary by provider).
AI will not simply be one more button in the interface. I believe it will reshape the way our industry operates.
While Media Traders are busy navigating an increasingly complex ecosystem — supply path optimisation (SPO), cookieless targeting, attention metrics, carbon footprints and everything in between — AI promises something rather appealing:
- Generating granular campaigns directly from an advertiser brief.
- Optimising delivery across thousands of signals.
- Automating creative production, A/B testing, analysis and reporting.
Less repetitive setup. More decisions made at machine speed. Sounds great… until we look at the org chart. 👀
From Media Trader to Programmatic AI Supervisor?
💡 My bet is that the Media Trader will increasingly become a Programmatic AI Supervisor: someone who sets objectives, checks outputs, challenges algorithms and takes responsibility for results.
💥 But here is the problem. My working estimate is that there are more than 700 Media Traders in the French advertising market (an indicative figure from my original commentary, not a verified employment census). How many of those roles will agencies need if one supervisor can eventually handle work that previously required a whole team?
This is a scenario, not an established workforce forecast. AI tools still need human oversight, and the pace of change will depend on performance, integration, governance and client expectations. But the economic question is already worth asking.
The problem for the agency business model
Many agencies still charge, at least in part, for allocated human resources. If AI dramatically reduces the hours needed to plan, activate and optimise campaigns, how do agencies defend their value — and their margins?
They could keep selling hours. Or they could start selling something different: expertise, infrastructure and new revenue opportunities for clients.
Could curation help advertisers build their own ad networks?
➡️ One serious opportunity: support the “ad-network-ification” of advertisers. We have already seen the logic in Retail Media. In my original analysis, I cited Retail Media at around 11% of the French market (the precise share depends on the year, advertising scope and measurement methodology).
Why should retailers have all the fun? Think banking, travel, fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG), automotive or technology. Some of these brands hold valuable, permissioned first-party audience data that other advertisers may want to reach.
Programmatic curation is the process of selecting advertising inventory and combining it with relevant data, quality rules or targeting signals to create curated deals that buyers can activate through a Deal ID.
With suitable technology and commercial agreements — potentially involving platforms such as Equativ, Xandr, Magnite, PubMatic or Index Exchange — advertisers could build an ad-network-like offer by:
- Accessing eligible publishers’ advertising inventory.
- Enriching that supply with their own authorised audience data.
- Packaging and monetising the resulting proposition through curated Deal IDs.
(This is not automatic: data permissions, privacy compliance, partner integrations, inventory rights and commercial demand all matter.)
A new job for agency trading teams
💡 Agencies could become architects and operators of advertiser-owned ad networks, redeploying Media Trading expertise into this new value chain.
- For advertisers: an opportunity to develop new revenue streams under budget pressure.
- For agencies: new advisory, technical and operational services instead of relying solely on trading hours.
- For Media Traders: a path towards product design, curation, governance and network operations.
It could also allow more advertising value to be created outside the largest closed platforms — provided the economics work in practice.
So, will AI replace Media Traders?
📉 My prediction: AI will substantially reduce the need for manual, operational media trading. That does not mean every Media Trader disappears. 📈 My opportunity: curation could help create a new media economy while preserving — and transforming — the usefulness of trading talent.
Agencies have a choice: wait for the automation wave to hit their billing model, or start building the next one.
A view from the French Open Web: GreyFox Ads
Here in France, we believe that quality French Open Web inventory can deliver real efficiency for advertisers. At GreyFox Ads, we like to call ourselves the smallest ad network in France. But not the dumbest. 🦊
Our Master Deal approach helps Media Traders access clean supply, smart targeting, operational simplicity and transparent costs through a streamlined programmatic activation. Explore our programmatic curation expertise to learn how we work.
Source and editorial notes
This article adapts my original LinkedIn post. The forecasts are my opinions; the French employment and Retail Media figures are contextual estimates from that post, not independently verified benchmarks. Named platforms are ecosystem examples, not claims of identical or currently available functionality.
Looking for a quality programmatic partner in France?
Planning a Video or Display campaign on the French Open Web? Let’s discuss quality inventory, curation and a simpler way to activate.