Menu

Programmatic Advertising: Are Carbon Footprint Scores Getting It Wrong?

Cartoon illustration about programmatic carbon footprint and ads.txt

Can a publisher's ads.txt file tell us how much carbon a programmatic campaign emits? Not on its own. Yet the number of declared advertising sellers is sometimes used as a proxy for supply-chain complexity. Here in France, that shortcut can create a very strange outcome: premium publishers risk being penalized while some Made for Advertising (MFA) sites appear comparatively clean. 🌍

Key takeaway

ads.txt is a transparency file, not a carbon meter. Counting declared SSP relationships does not reveal how many bid requests were actually sent, how much computing was used, or the energy footprint of the page itself. Better carbon optimization means measuring real activity and removing wasteful supply paths.

What does ads.txt actually tell us?

ads.txt (Authorized Digital Sellers) is an IAB Tech Lab standard through which publishers publicly declare companies authorized to sell their advertising inventory. It helps buyers identify legitimate selling relationships. It was not designed to measure greenhouse gas emissions.

Some carbon-oriented screening approaches use the number or structure of declared supply relationships as one indicator of potential programmatic complexity. The logic sounds reasonable: more intermediaries could mean more processing and duplicated auction traffic. But could is doing a lot of work here. A declaration is not evidence of an active auction.

Three blind spots in ads.txt-based carbon scoring

1. Are all declared SSP seats actually active?

No. An ads.txt file may include historical or rarely used seller relationships. In France, publishers including Prisma Media and groups associated with Les Echos, Le Parisien and Paris Match have been discussed in the context of ads.txt clean-ups. Removing declarations without a meaningful revenue impact is consistent with some relationships having little commercial value (although revenue stability alone does not establish their actual energy consumption).

Counting every entry as if it generated the same amount of traffic can therefore misrepresent the real activity of a publisher's supply chain.

2. Does every SSP receive every bid request?

No. Programmatic platforms can use throttling, traffic shaping and other controls to avoid sending requests unlikely to result in a transaction. Their implementation varies by platform, buyer and auction path. A declared seller may be called rarely, or not at all, for a given impression.

To assess carbon impact, the useful question is not simply “How many SSPs are listed?” but “How many actual requests, responses and processing steps did this impression generate?”

3. Is a website's footprint limited to its advertising stack?

Absolutely not. Image and video weight, page design, hosting, content delivery, device processing and the advertising stack can all contribute to energy use. Geography and electricity mix may also matter to a full emissions model.

A site with fewer declared sellers can still deliver heavyweight pages, aggressive ad refreshes and an excessive number of ads. A simple ads.txt count would miss that.

The MFA paradox: when “cleaner” does not mean better

Here is the uncomfortable part. Some Made for Advertising (MFA) websites optimize primarily for advertising volume rather than audience value. They may use ad clutter, frequent refreshes or repetitive auctions. If a carbon score rewards a short ads.txt file without adequately measuring these behaviors, an MFA site could appear more favorable than a premium publisher.

That is a risk of an incomplete scoring method, not proof that all carbon measurement providers make this mistake. Different providers use different models and inputs, which should be examined individually.

How can programmatic buyers reduce unnecessary emissions?

My preferred approach is simple: stop paying for unnecessary complexity. Better supply quality can support both operational efficiency and campaign effectiveness.

ActionWhy it mattersWhat to verify
Supply Path Optimization (SPO)Reduce redundant reselling paths and unnecessary intermediaries.Actual auction paths, fees and request volumes.
Exclude low-quality MFA inventoryAvoid ad clutter, excessive refreshes and inventory designed primarily to multiply impressions.Domain/subdomain-level controls and measurable inventory quality.
Prioritize impactful formatsFavor placements that give the creative meaningful screen space and exposure.Attention, outcomes and emissions together; smaller ads are not automatically less efficient.
Measure real trafficMove beyond seller declarations to actual bid requests and delivered assets.Methodology, boundaries and independently comparable data.

Take the familiar 320×50 or 728×90 banner. A small format can use fewer bytes, but if it generates little attention, is it really an efficient use of resources? That's the question I want buyers to ask (the answer depends on campaign goals and verified outcomes, not format size alone).

Our approach at GreyFox Ads: cleaner supply, smarter buying

At GreyFox Ads, our view is that the quality French Open Web can deliver real efficiency for advertisers. We are the smallest ad network in France — but not the dumbest. 😉

Our Master Deal is built around four priorities: clean supply, smart targeting, simplicity and cost transparency. Through programmatic curation, we aim to make quality French inventory easier to activate without multiplying unnecessary supply paths.

Conclusion: measure what happens, not just what is declared

ads.txt is essential for seller transparency. But a file listing authorized sellers cannot, by itself, tell us the carbon footprint of a programmatic campaign. If we want genuinely greener media buying, we need to examine real auction activity, actual page weight, supply-chain waste and campaign effectiveness.

Less useless pollution. Better advertising. That's a trade-off worth pursuing.

Source and methodology

This article adapts my original LinkedIn post. The examples reflect my analysis of the French programmatic market; they are not an independent carbon audit. For the purpose and technical specification of ads.txt, see IAB Tech Lab. Actual emissions require an explicit measurement methodology and defined system boundaries.

About the author

Max Legrand is the founder of GreyFox Ads, an independent French programmatic curation specialist focused on quality inventory, the Open Web and effective media buying.

Looking for a quality programmatic partner in France?

Planning a display or video campaign on the French Open Web? Let's discuss clean supply, targeting and transparent costs.

Contact GreyFox AdsExplore the Master Deal