Menu

The Vicious Cycle of Bid Repeating in Programmatic Advertising 🐍

By Max Legrand · GreyFox Ads · French Open Web insights

Bid repeating and DSP throttling in the programmatic advertising supply chain

More bid requests. More SSP connections. More chances to win a bid? Not necessarily. In programmatic advertising, multiplying the same opportunity across supply paths can trigger the very filters that make publisher inventory harder to buy.

In brief: Bid repeating is the repeated transmission of the same or equivalent ad opportunity through multiple auction paths. It can increase processing costs and encourage DSP throttling, without proportionally increasing impressions sold or publisher revenue. Our illustrative French publisher comparison showed a 95% gap between two bid-request volume measures (not a market-wide throttling rate).
In this article

1. What is bid repeating in programmatic advertising?

Well, well, well… French digital media publication Journal du Net (JDN) beat us to this topic! See the JDN discussion. We'd had this post waiting in the wings for a while. 😂 But here's our take.

There is an open secret on the sell side: a publisher's share of programmatic buying opportunities is not always proportional to its real audience. It can also depend on how many bid requests (BRs) that pass buyers' filters the publisher sends into the ecosystem.

Bid repeating occurs when a single advertising opportunity, or substantially the same opportunity, is exposed repeatedly to buyers through multiple SSP connections, exchange seats or reseller paths. A publisher may generate many auction messages without creating any additional page views, users or actual ad slots.

For example, distributing an opportunity across 15 seats could theoretically create up to 15 request paths. That is an illustration, not a guarantee of 15 identical requests (auction settings, filtering and demand integrations differ).

2. Why can bid repeating hurt SSPs, DSPs and publishers?

Here is the catch: 15 times more bid requests does not mean 15 times more publisher revenue. Each additional request can consume infrastructure, networking and processing resources, while SSPs and DSPs generally monetize completed transactions rather than every auction message.

So publishers may appear to multiply the loaves… while burning through the bidders' flour. 🥖🔥

What increasesWhat does not automatically increase
Bid requests and auction trafficUnique users or page views
Compute and network processingActual impressions available to sell
Overlapping SSP/reseller pathsAdvertiser value or publisher yield
Difficulty distinguishing supply pathsBuyer willingness to bid

When bidders face excessive low-value or redundant requests, they may apply throttling: filtering or sampling requests before full bid evaluation. Our earlier explainer covers how bid-request throttling works.

3. Our case study: a 95% gap in available bid requests

Think throttling is a tiny, marginal phenomenon? We ran a small investigation here in France.

  1. From a curator seat, we examined the bid-request volume sent toward DSPs by an exchange's SSP seats for a major news publisher.
  2. We compared that figure with the estimated available bid-request volume shown for the same publisher and exchange in a DSP planner, using the open auction.

The observed gap was 95%. 😱 In other words, the planner's estimate was approximately 5% of the volume observed from the curator-side view.

Methodological note: this is one publisher, one exchange and one specific comparison of two different reporting perspectives. Differences in scope, timing, eligibility and estimation methods may contribute to the gap. It should not be treated as a measured industry-wide throttling rate or proof that every missing request was filtered solely because of bid repeating.

4. How does bid repeating create a vicious cycle?

Here's where the snake starts eating its own tail. 🐍

  1. Publishers add SSP and reseller connections to increase demand exposure and the number of auction opportunities sent.
  2. Overlapping bid requests increase, adding cost and complexity for buying platforms.
  3. DSPs throttle or prioritize supply to protect processing capacity and focus on opportunities with a better expected return.
  4. Some publishers see less effective demand access and respond by adding even more reseller paths.
  5. The cycle repeats: more duplication, more filtering, more intermediaries and potentially less transparent economics.

Our separate example of reseller-heavy auction traffic discusses cases where reseller seats account for as much as 80% of bid requests on a particular exchange. That figure is contextual, not a universal share across the Open Web.

5. Can Transaction IDs help identify duplicate auctions?

A Transaction ID (TID) can help authorized buyers and platforms recognize when multiple requests may relate to the same underlying advertising opportunity. But identification is not always straightforward: TID availability, consistency and implementation can vary across the supply chain.

That's why the debate around transaction IDs and auction transparency matters. A TID is useful evidence for analyzing duplication, not a magic solution that automatically eliminates every redundant request.

The same logic applies to header bidding wrappers and complex reseller chains: more connections can improve competition, but the value of each additional path should be tested rather than assumed.

6. How can the industry reduce unnecessary bid repeating?

The answer is not to disconnect every reseller. Some intermediaries deliver genuine incremental demand or capabilities. The goal is to identify paths that add value and remove those that merely duplicate access.

For advertisers, the goal is not the highest number of bid requests. It is the best route to real, valuable impressions.

7. How GreyFox Ads approaches bid repeating and SPO

At GreyFox Ads, we're a French programmatic curation company focused on making high-quality Open Web advertising simpler and more transparent.

We prioritize SSP seats operated directly by publishers, alongside resellers that demonstrably provide additional value. That helps avoid unnecessary intermediary paths rather than adding them for the sake of volume.

Our Master Curated Deal also combines MFA filtering, brand safety, attention-oriented format selection, privacy-appropriate audience strategies and visibility into programmatic costs.

Simple. Fast. Effective. And hopefully fewer snakes eating their own tails. 😉

Further reading: Journal du Net discussion · Transaction ID discussion · Throttling discussion · Reseller bid requests discussion.

Original LinkedIn post: Read the original post.

About the author

Max Legrand founded GreyFox Ads, an independent French programmatic curation company focused on Open Web quality, efficiency and transparency.

Looking for a quality-focused programmatic advertising partner?

Let's talk about supply path optimization, efficient curated deals and better Display and Video buying in France.

Contact GreyFox AdsDiscover the Master Deal