Menu

Programmatic Advertising: Why MFA Websites Are a Serious Threat to the Open Web

Made for Advertising websites and their impact on the quality Open Web

Made for Advertising (MFA) websites are not just annoying. They can undermine the user experience, distort programmatic buying signals and divert advertising budgets away from publishers investing in genuine content. Here in France, we decided to investigate the problem using bid requests per page view.

Key takeaway. In a GreyFox Ads analysis covering more than 500 major French websites, the average observed ratio was 17 bid requests per page view. Some sites exceeded 500. Sites with ratios above 100 accounted for 30% of the bid requests analysed. This is a useful screening signal—not proof that every high-ratio site is MFA.

What are Made for Advertising (MFA) websites?

You've probably encountered them: websites or subdomains where the content feels buried beneath an avalanche of advertising. Their business model may depend heavily on generating ad impressions rather than delivering a valuable editorial experience.

Three groups can lose out: users, who struggle to read the content; advertisers, whose messages compete with excessive clutter and may suffer from poor brand associations; and quality publishers, whose original journalism or content must compete for the same budgets.

Of course, ad density alone does not establish that a publisher is MFA. Classification requires a broader assessment of content, user experience and monetisation practices.

How MFA websites can exploit programmatic buying signals

Programmatic buying systems can reward inventory that appears to offer abundant supply, strong viewability, high click-through rates and low CPMs. Depending on the DSP's optimisation objectives and quality controls, these signals can create opportunities for MFA operators.

Buying signalPossible MFA tacticWhy buyers should care
High bid-request volumeDense ad layouts, aggressive ad refresh and multiple ad opportunities per pageLarge volumes do not necessarily mean incremental human reach
High viewabilityMultiple sticky placementsA technically viewable impression does not guarantee attention
High CTRIntrusive or delayed mobile placements that can trigger accidental tapsClicks may overstate genuine interest
Low CPMVery low floor prices, sometimes around €0.05 in the examples we observedCheap impressions can still be inefficient

That is also why attention and viewability should not be treated as interchangeable metrics.

Our analysis: bid requests per page view across 500+ French websites

At GreyFox Ads, we analysed more than 500 of the largest websites in France, comparing observed bid-request volumes after SSP throttling (where accessible through buying tools) with site-centric page-view estimates from web intelligence services such as Similarweb.

IndicatorObserved resultInterpretation
Average bid requests / page view17Reference point within our analysed sample
Highest observed ratios500+Extreme values warranting further investigation
Share of analysed bid requests from sites with ratio >10030%A material concentration of supply in high-ratio environments

Important methodological nuance: these figures describe our observation perimeter, not a census of the French Open Web. Bid requests are not impressions, and post-throttling request volumes can vary by DSP, exchange, device, ad format and measurement period. Page-view estimates can also differ from publishers' own analytics. The ratio is a diagnostic signal, not a universal industry benchmark or a standalone MFA verdict.

How can Media Traders identify and avoid MFA inventory?

Start by combining supply-side signals with actual site reviews, rather than relying on a single KPI:

  1. Compare bid requests with page views. Investigate unusually high ratios and check whether refresh or ad density explains them.
  2. Review the user experience. Look at ad clutter, sticky units, disruptive placements and the quality of the editorial content.
  3. Analyse performance beyond CTR and CPM. Include attention, meaningful outcomes and brand suitability where measurement is available.
  4. Review supply paths. Limit unnecessary intermediaries and check the origin of inventory. Our article on resellers and Supply Path Optimisation (SPO) explains why this matters.
  5. Use curated, documented supply. Maintain clear inclusion and exclusion rules, then revisit them as inventory changes.

Environmental scoring also deserves scrutiny: our article on MFA websites and carbon-footprint measurement explains why simplistic supply-chain proxies can mislead.

Why MFA is a problem for the quality Open Web

When an advertiser's budget goes to pages engineered primarily to monetise ad calls, less money may reach publishers that invest in useful content. If buying algorithms optimise to easy-to-game proxies, that can reinforce the wrong incentives.

Our position at GreyFox Ads is simple: the quality French Open Web can deliver real advertising efficiency—provided buyers can distinguish valuable supply from inflated volume.

We may be the smallest ad network in France, but not the dumbest. Our Master Deals are designed to give Media Traders clean supply, smart targeting, operational simplicity and cost transparency, including MFA exclusions.

About the author

is the founder of GreyFox Ads, a French independent programmatic curation specialist focused on the quality Open Web, transparency and effective advertising.

Read the original LinkedIn post

Looking for quality programmatic supply in France?

Challenge your video or display buying strategy with curated inventory, MFA exclusions and transparent supply paths.

Contact GreyFox AdsDiscover the Master Deal